This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Lowe's Heartland Sheds vs. Home Depot's Tuff Shed
I've seen Tuff Sheds for sale at Home Depot for years.
So I decided to check it out ifIt was time to replace the 20 year old metal shed that was rusting in my backyard.
I couldn't be happier with my new Tuff Shed. It has improved the look of my garden and serves me as an attractive and organized workshop!
Best of all, I purchased this Tuff Shed from a nearby Home Depot location as a former model who spent over a year as a display case in the store's parking lot. It was offered at a deep discount - amounting to approx$1,000 off the purchase price of the same model new.
So yes I got a discount on the new shed which I am reviewing here. But then again, that's only because it was a parking lot model. No one associated with Tuff Shed or Home Depot knew I was a blogger and journalist. They also didn't know that I was planning to overhaul my new shed. Having said all that, I would like to continue with my Tuff Shed review.
Why I decided to buy a new woodshed
IfI bought my housea few years ago there were only a fewThings I would like to renovate or change in the near future:
- move stove.
- Adding a door under the garage to the laundry area in the adjacent pantry.
- Remodeling of the showerin my only bathroom for a bathtub.
- Removing an old shed and replacing it with a more attractive, spacious shed with more storage and worktop space.
I had been casually looking for sheds since I bought my house - and I took note of what I found on the market.
I am a frequent buyer ofLoweseHeimdepot- Both have shops within a 10 minute drive of my house. I love both of these great hardware stores. And both offer an enticing selection of woodsheds.
Lowes CarregaHeartland Scales, and Home Depot carriestuff scales.
Both shed manufacturers offer a variety of configurations—including standard, semi-custom, and custom log sheds.
RELATED: The Home Depot shoreline spilled them+8 Ways to Create Your Own She Shed
I was a bit on the fence about what type of shed to buy and where to buy it.
I even went shopping at local shed companies to check out their different models and options.
So I wanted to buy a wooden shed. But to make sureI've also looked at metal scales and plastic scales:
- unfortunately,Metal scales can rust- like my existing one. And I didn't want another rusty metal flake on my hands in a few years.
- I had a little plastic shed once. It's still standing after almost 20 years (now in my sister and brother-in-law's garden). It has served me well and now my sister and her husband - but they are willing to replace it. OThe plastic siding of the shed begins to deform, allowing water to enter the shed.
Tuff Shed vs. Heartland Shed (Home Depot vs. Lowes Sheds)
When deciding to buy a new wood shed, I spent a lot of time comparing products from Tuff Shed at Home Depot and Heartland Sheds at Lowe's.
Both manufacturers seem to offer excellent wooden sheds. ButThe more I shopped, the more I realized that Tuff Shed was just the ticket For me.
As a homeowner in Florida living 20 miles from the coast, I wanted a shed that could withstand not only the heat but also the water. And in central Florida, we get a lot of wind—from hurricanes and storms in the summer and cold fronts in the fall, winter, and spring.
In my Tuff Shed review below,I'll add some key comparisons between Lowe's Heartland Sheds and Home Depot's Tuff Sheds.
My Tuff Shed Review Vergleich Tuff Shed vs. Heartland Shed
Die Stiftung: Tuff Shed vs. Heartland Shed
We don't really deal with snow in Florida except on very rare occasions. Snow loads on the roof were therefore not a problem for me. But we got a lot of rain. And moisture is not very friendly to wooden structures.
That was the first thing that struck me between Tuff Sheds and Heartland Sheds... Although both are made of wood,Their bases are different:
- Lowe's Heartland sheds have a wooden base.
- Home Depot's Tuff sheds are constructed with a galvanized steel frame.
Now it's important to note that Heartland Sheds claims that their wooden foundations are treated against insects and moisture. And I firmly believe that they are.
But I felt safer with a metal base. Maybe I would worry less if I bought a shed for a house in New England. But Florida not only has rain, it also has termites. ThenThe galvanized metal base gives me more security.
Floors and Walls: Heartland Vs. Tufa Scales
For me, Tuff Shed already led the way with the galvanized steel foundation. But I was even more confident when I compared the specs to the floors and walls!
ÖThe floors in the Tuff Sheds and the Heartland Sheds look more or less the sameFor me
ButI noticed a big difference in the construction of the walls:
- Heartland Sheds spaced their pins 24 inches apart on the models I looked at.
- Tuff Shed places its cleats just 16 inches apart.
I assume both shed manufacturers comply with local wind codes, but I felt more comfortable having a shed with pegs further apart. Generally,The closer the pins, the more durable the structure.
It's important to remember thatbothHome Depot Tuff Shed and Lowe's Heartland Sheds use 2×4″ cleats – which are much sturdier than the 2×3″ cleats I've seen in other sheds.
Roof: Tuff Shelter vs. Heartland Refuge
There are also differences between Home Depot's Tuff Shed roofs and Lowe's Heartland Shed roofs:
- Tuff Shed models ship with the roof and shingles installed.
- Heartland Sheds requires that you purchase clapboard or other siding material for the outer shell separately.
Exterior Livery: Heartland Sheds vs. Tufa Sheds
I'll give it to Tuff Shed and Heartland Sheds... Both companies make beautiful wooden sheds!
Seriously, I didn't have a preference between the two manufacturers in terms of external aspects. I would have been proud to own a Tuff Shed or Heartland Shed based on the looks of it.
Both shed companies use engineered wood products and durable paneling or other finishing materials to keep out insects, moisture, and other nasty things.
and bothTuff Shed and Heartland Sheds offer a ton of exterior options to customize your shed exactly how you want it..
Options include different styles of:
- windows and blinds
- storage facilities
All of these options offer plenty of opportunities to customize your shed to match the look of your home and landscape!
Cost: Tuff Shed vs. Kernland Schuppen
OK,This is where the Home Depot Tuff Shed and Lowe's Heartland Sheds differ a bit.
Heartland sheds tend to be cheaperto buy as Tuff Sheds.
The difference in price is mainly due to the fact that:
- Tuff Sheds are installed or delivered on site by the Tuff Shed teamor approved contractors on site - and your hall can be fully used on the same day.
- Heartland sheds can be built as a do-it-yourself project or installed professionally. So if you're savvy and have some free time, maybe you could install your own Heartland Shed over the course of a few weekends.
Prices vary from model to model between Tuff Shed and Heartland Sheds. that's how it seemed to meThe price of an installed Tuff Shed was about 30% more expensivethan an equivalent Heartland Shed purchased as a kit. (Don't forget that you'll also need to purchase the tiles for the Heartland Scale separately. Buying tiles for your Heartland Scale doesn't have to be expensive, though.)
If you want a fun do-it-yourself project, you can probably build a Heartland Shed for a lot less money than the cost of buying and installing a Tuff Shed.
However,If, like me, you're short on time and intend to have your Heartland Shed professionally installed on site, the cost savings on the Heartland Shed virtually disappear.
You pay a separate price to have your Heartland Shed professionally installed - and that cost can easily run into hundreds of dollars or more, depending on the model.
What is the Tuff Shed installation process like?
Remember,I bought a ready assembled display model- so I didn't build my Tuff Shed on site. It was delivered and assembled in one piece.
So my review of Tuff Shed here is not based on the company building a shed on the site.
However, the team that came to install my shed is the same people who build Tuff Sheds from scratch. (I know this because I spoke to the Tuff Shed team who came to my house and they told me that they personally build Tuff Sheds too.)
My experience with the team at Tuff Shed was fantastic from start to finish. My sales representative promptly answered my calls and texts and politely answered all of my questions.
I didn't know what to expect from the Tuff Shed installation team - but they were also a pleasure to work with.
The team of two was extremely professional. One of the two guys, a person who had worked for Tuff Shed for several years, offered me all kinds of maintenance and care tips.He told meExactlyhow to keep my shed in good condition for years to come.
Maintenance tips for tuff scales
Here are some of themTips the Tuff Shed installer shared with me:
- Paint your tuff wood shedevery few years – to keep the exterior in an attractive condition.
- Keep mulch and other landscaping materials away from the bottom edge of the wood trim— to reduce wood rot.
- Avoid adjacent landscaping materials that could ricochet and bring water under the fairing- Again, water getting under the wood paneling can encourage the development of rot.
- Keep tall plants farther from the foundation to prevent roots from growing under the Tuff Shed.- However, the planting around the shed is fine.
- Do not install self-adhesive flooring in your shed– may void the warranty.
MONITORING:I applied a new floor color to my Tuff Shed to refresh the interior of this old floor model. However, I called my Tuff Shed sales representative beforehand to make sure I was using paint that would not void my shed's multi-year warranty. I recommend you contact your Tuff Shed representative for the same advice to avoid future problems with an invalid warranty.
Do you need a permit to build a tuff shed?
At 120 square feet, my 10'x12' TR-700 Tuff shed is smaller than the 150 square foot limit forneed a licenseInstall a shed in my community.
However,Many communities require a permit to build a shedanysize or material. Therefore, I recommend that you call your county's zoning and licensing department to ensure you have the necessary legal permits to build a shed on your home.
Also, check your neighborhood codes to ensure your new shed complies with applicable Homeowners Association (HOA) rules.
How's my new wood tufa shed?
In case you were wondering if tuff sheds are any good and if I would ever get one again knowing what I know now... My answer is YES!
My new Tuff Shed is wonderful to own and a joy to use.
I got pretty much everything out of my old metal shed right away. Everything fits perfectly in my new tuff wood shed -Ö The storage and organization inside is amazing.
One of the biggest improvements for me is thisI have a lot more headroom in the Tuff Shed:
- My old shed is about 2 meters high in the middle - exactly my height. The side walls are only about 5 feet tall, so I had to squat a lot to get around my old shed.
- My new Tuff Shed has a 6'2″ door, 7ft high sidewalls and a 9ft high roof peak – so it's just the right size for me.
I plan to hire a licensed electrician to install lighting and an electrical outlet in my Tuff Shed— so that I can use it as a fully functional workshop. I love carpentry and look forward to doing all sorts of things in my new shed!
RELATED: The world's largest collection of 16,000 woodworking plans
I have had no problems with my new Tuff Shed.
Several storms passed and not a drop of rain fell. The interior of the shed smells of wood - there is no mold or mildew. And that's very good!
Also, my shed window really brings in a lot of nice daylight.
also with discountmy tuff shed was a significant 4 figure investment. But I'm really glad I did. I expect my new woodshed will last for decades. Who knows? Maybe even my grandkids will step on it one day!
Tuff Sheds in the news
Around the time I started looking for a new shed - right after I bought my house - I saw an article on the news about Tuff Sheds (don't worry...it was good news!)
The City of Oakland, California has purchased dozens of Tuff Sheds for constructiona community of small houses that provides temporary housing for the homeless.
EThe officeatorAngela Kinsey took to social media with her personal Tuff ShedRefuge known as the"She poured that."(You must knowThe office, which aired on NBC from 2005 to 2013 to get that hilarious inside joke!)
RELATED: My top tips for a Dunder Mifflin tour from Scranton, PA to see the landmarks featured on The Office TV show
Do you like this post?rette isto revisit later...or share with others on Pinterest!
I'm a roller coaster addict, weather enthusiast, frequent traveler and numismatist. My love for coins started when I was 11 years old. I mainly collect and study US coins made in the 20th century. I am a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and the Numismatic Literary Guild (NLG). I also study meteorology and have been observing weather patterns for years. I enjoy sharing little known facts and fun stuff about currencies, weather, travel, health, food and green living... on a budget. I work from home full-time as a journalist, reporter and writer.
What is comparable to Tuff Shed? ›
Tuff Shed's competitors and similar companies include CubeSmart, Life Storage, Trojan Storage and Safeguard Self Storage.Are Tuff sheds made of wood? ›
Manufacturer and retailer of storage buildings and garages made of wood or steel for residential and commercial applications.Can a person live in a Tuff Shed? ›
While the thought of making a tiny home out of a shed might seem unconventional, choosing a Tuff Shed may be the right fit for you. Not only do you have many stylistic options, but your custom home can be had for a fraction of the cost of a traditional home.Is it cheaper to build your own Tuff Shed? ›
If you've been wondering if is it cheaper to build your own shed, you'll discover that yes, it is less expensive to build your own shed than to purchase a pre-built shed. That is at least if you have all the tools required to build the shed. Typically, it won't take many specialty tools to build the shed.What is the most durable type of shed? ›
wood. Resin is the most durable because it's weather-resistant to fading, rusting, warping, rotting, insects, and fire. Assembly is the final factor to consider when purchasing a shed.What is the best base for a Tuff Shed? ›
A gravel pad (crushed stone) with a lumber perimeter is the best shed foundation option in most cases. We recommend gravel shed foundations because they provide a stable base for your shed to rest on and do a great job of draining water away from the bottom of your shed.Does Tuff Shed build in the rain? ›
installation. Rain, snow, and sleet will most likely not prevent installation.Can a Tuff Shed sit on the dirt? ›
The two different types of Tuff Shed floor joists are designed to be able to be placed directly on dirt, gravel, grass, concrete or other firm, dry and level surfaces. We always recommend that customers check with their municipality to see if there are any different local requirements for the building foundation.What is the average lifespan of a shed? ›
You can easily expect a Glick Woodworks wooden shed to last between 20 and 25 years, and with careful maintenance, they may even last longer. As a wooden building, these sheds will be susceptible to rot and mold. In order to delay those issues, make sure you keep a good coat of paint on the entire building.How long does it take for a Tuff Shed to be built? ›
For installation of storage sheds, you can typically expect the builders to finish and clean up the job site in less than a day's time (8 hours).
Can you turn a Tuff Shed into a house? ›
The main pro of a shed is that it could allow you to build out a home for less money than a traditional house. But like we said before, you'll still have to build a foundation, add insulation to the walls, put in utilities, and complete the interior finishing.What is the average monthly payment on a Tuff Shed? ›
The Tuff Shed Building
For a 10×10 Tuff Shed building in your backyard, the average monthly payment is around $86.
A 10×12 Storage Shed is a Cost Saver. Since there are fewer materials needed for a 10×12 storage shed, the cost will be less than a larger 12×20 shed. Go really economical and buy the economy shed and you could have a shed in your backyard for less than you would think.Should I buy a shed kit or build from scratch? ›
Custom-built sheds are better quality and tailor-made
Spending less on a kit will save money in the present, but buying a more expensive custom-built shed will save you money over time. Along with the options to have them either delivered to your property or built on site by an experienced construction team.
The only time you wouldn't need some sort of foundation is if you have a very small 6×6 or 8×8 shed that is made out of rubber or plastic. And even in that case, we still highly recommend a gravel foundation to keep that little plastic shed from sinking into the ground or experience moisture problems as time goes on.What sheds won't rot? ›
Plastic: Plastic sheds won't rot, they require almost no maintenance, and they tend to be lightweight, making them easy to assemble.What is the best type of wooden shed? ›
Tongue and groove sheds are similar to shiplap and are usually regarded as being the highest quality wooden sheds.Should I paint the floor of my Tuff Shed? ›
Painting your shed's floor can be a great idea to protect and seal the wood. It also reduces splinters, is easy to clean, and it enhances the shed's look. It will be easiest to paint your shed floor when it is new and barely used.What is the best shed floor? ›
Plywood can give your shed a seamless floor that is smooth enough for objects to slide across it with ease. It can be painted to seal it as well as add to the aesthetic of the shed, and it is easy to sweep clean. If pressure treated plywood is used, then the flooring will be resistant to moisture or water damage.Can I upgrade my Tuff Shed? ›
Tuff Shed - A metal roof upgrade is a great way to add some sturdy style to your storage shed, big or small.
Why put gravel under shed? ›
Gravel is the best type of foundation for your shed
First off, it drains much better than a flat concrete pad. That'll help protect the runners and joists under your shed from rotting and decaying. Second, it supports your shed much better shed foundation blocks.
How big should the base be? Your base should normally be about the same size as the floor of your shed. Some people like to create a larger base or lay paving slabs around the outside of their shed. This allows for easier, cleaner access and space to empty out items onto a hardstanding area.Should you waterproof the inside of a shed? ›
The importance of shed waterproofing
Waterproofing your shed helps keep both the garden building and its contents in good condition. Why? Because too much moisture can rot wood (especially if left untreated).
Installing a damp-proof membrane in (or under) the shed base is one way of insulating the building from the threat of damp. This is because a shed membrane can help prevent the build-up of water underneath the shed, thereby protecting it against rising damp.Where not to put a shed? ›
However, it's generally not advised to put your shed up against a side wall, because of the inevitable gap that it creates. No shed sits flush to a wall – the vast majority of sheds have gutters or small overhangs on the roof, which cause a gap of some description.Should I put plastic under shed floor? ›
Without a barrier, water vapor can enter the shed through the floor, which can rust the tools you store there. Many people don't realize you can buy treated plywood. You rarely find this at home centers, but traditional lumberyards usually stock this fantastic product.Is it OK to put shed on grass? ›
Using dirt, lawn or gravel for the base: Never attempt to erect your garden shed directly on bare ground, gravel, or lawn. This could damage the wood panels due to moisture from the ground and also lead to warping and subsidence.What time of year is cheapest to buy a shed? ›
Buying Sheds in the Fall
For many home improvement stores, shed retailers, and shed manufacturers, the end of their peak shed buying season is when they're willing to offer discounts or clearance prices. Doing this helps them to get in as many sales as possible before the year closes.
Sturdy and waterproof materials are the best for use on a shed roof or garden building. Here at Roofing Superstore, we'd recommend using felt, bitumen roof sheets, bitumen shingles, plastic lightweight roof tiles, or wood shingles to secure an attractive, long-term waterproof roof.How much should I spend on a shed? ›
A backyard storage or tool shed costs between $1,875 and $8,250, or an average of about $3,350. Homeowners typically spend between $1,875 and $8,250 on storage sheds. The national average cost for utility sheds is $3,350. For many people, a basic backyard shed is an absolute necessity.
Should a shed be on a concrete slab? ›
Concrete offers the best support for vehicles, tractors and heavy equipment. If you're installing a larger structure that will store vehicles, concrete might be your best bet. For smaller sheds used for general storage and workspaces, gravel and wood foundations will work great.Can Tuff sheds be insulated? ›
If you're turning your Tuff Shed into an actual, usable guest room or potting shed, one of the first things you'll need to do is to insulate it ~ particularly if you live in a place with temperature extremes.Can you drywall a Tuff Shed? ›
With a little DIY work or by hiring out a contractor, you can add interior finishing touches like insulation, drywall, lighting, flooring and furniture to fulfill your big project dreams.How much does a Tuff Shed home conversion cost? ›
The Cost of Building a Tuff Shed Tiny House
According to Home Depot's website, the lowest cost of a tiny home kit that includes hardware is about $20,000. More expensive options can be about $65,000.
Sheds usually have small windows for ventilation, which means it uses more electricity to power the heat or air conditioner. Lastly, sheds are not built to protect against winter weather. If there were a severe storm, like a tornado or a hurricane, people who live in sheds could lose their homes.What is the estimated cost of a 10x20 shed? ›
10×20 shed prices range from $4,752 to $33,013 and above, depending on building design, style, siding, add-ons, and more.How much should I charge for labor to build a shed? ›
Labor. Hire a handyperson for help building a prefabricated shed for between $60 and $125 per hour, or for a flat rate based on the extent of the project. Keep in mind that some prefab sheds come with installation assistance built into the price.Are sheds a good investment? ›
If you are looking for a cost-effective way to add value to your home, building a shed is one of the best options you can choose. It can improve your living space, make your outdoor living area more enjoyable and increase the value of your property.What is the longest lasting material for a shed? ›
wood. Resin is the most durable because it's weather-resistant to fading, rusting, warping, rotting, insects, and fire. Assembly is the final factor to consider when purchasing a shed. Some wooden sheds are already built and just require you to install them.How much should I charge to build a 10x10 shed? ›
The average cost for the construction of a DIY shed as shared by DIY Enthusiast, Eugene Kokol, runs anywhere from $17 to $24 per square feet. So, with the projected price per square feet, a DIY 10×10 Shed would cost anywhere from $1,700 – $2,400.
What foundation is best for a shed? ›
What is the best shed foundation? A gravel pad (crushed stone) with a lumber perimeter is the best shed foundation option in most cases. We recommend gravel shed foundations because they provide a stable base for your shed to rest on and do a great job of draining water away from the bottom of your shed.Who are Tuff shed competitors? ›
Tuff Shed's competitors and similar companies include CubeSmart, Life Storage, Trojan Storage and Safeguard Self Storage.Is it cheaper to buy a tuff shed or build your own? ›
If you've been wondering if is it cheaper to build your own shed, you'll discover that yes, it is less expensive to build your own shed than to purchase a pre-built shed. That is at least if you have all the tools required to build the shed. Typically, it won't take many specialty tools to build the shed.What is the best shed flooring options? ›
Pressure-treated plywood is one of the best options for shed flooring. Pressure-treated plywood is resistant to wood rot, insects, and water. It is also easy to paint and sweep. A downside of pressure-treated plywood is that even though it is pressure-treated, it can still suffer corrosion and weather over time.What is the cheapest easiest shed foundation? ›
Concrete block shed foundations are popular because they are cheap, easy to install, and easy to use for leveling sheds on slopes.
The Cost of Building a Tuff Shed Tiny House
According to Home Depot's website, the lowest cost of a tiny home kit that includes hardware is about $20,000. More expensive options can be about $65,000.
You can even add transom windows to your door, among other upgrades. No matter what options and upgrades you choose for your Tuff Shed building, you can be confident in the strength and longevity of your building, all backed by our industry-leading warranties.Is wood or vinyl better for a shed? ›
Risk of Rot — When it comes to stopping mold and rot, vinyl is the best shed material and there's no question about it. After all, your home is probably built from vinyl siding, and that's no coincidence. However, as a naturally occurring material — even treated wood — can be damaged by rot and mold.What is the best sheet material for shed floor? ›
Shed floors are best done with plywood. The wood of normal exterior plywood is not particularly resistant to rot, as it is glued with weather-resistant glue. For that reason, pressure-treated plywood is best for use as a shed floor.Is wood shed floor better than concrete? ›
Also, concrete attracts and holds lots of moisture, which can cause rust and rot on the items that are stored inside of the shed. With a wooden floor, you eliminate those concerns because the floor breathes, and doesn't hold moisture, resulting in a very dry storage environment.
Should shed foundation be larger than shed? ›
How big should the base be? Your base should normally be about the same size as the floor of your shed. Some people like to create a larger base or lay paving slabs around the outside of their shed. This allows for easier, cleaner access and space to empty out items onto a hardstanding area.What shed does not need a foundation? ›
The only time you wouldn't need some sort of foundation is if you have a very small 6×6 or 8×8 shed that is made out of rubber or plastic. And even in that case, we still highly recommend a gravel foundation to keep that little plastic shed from sinking into the ground or experience moisture problems as time goes on.How long does it take for a Tuff shed to be built? ›
For installation of storage sheds, you can typically expect the builders to finish and clean up the job site in less than a day's time (8 hours).Do Tuff sheds have floors? ›
Our floors are so innovative and durable, they set us apart. TUFF SHED revolutionized the shed industry by incorporating 2″x6″ hot-dipped galvanized steel floor joists, ensuring the building's solid foundation for years to come.Can you add a window to a Tuff Shed? ›
Our standard shed door is already legendary in quality…and now you can upgrade the look of your TUFF SHED storage building with windows that are both functional and asthetically pleasing.